If you have recently installed WWE 2K23 and are only able to select the Play Mode option with One on One matches and limited Superstars, then you’ve likely found yourself in Demo Mode. This issue usually happens when the game is still downloading/installing or patching.
When you go to your game store download menu, make sure to check that the game is fully downloaded. You'll see a displayed percent that should tell you how close you are - hang in there until it reaches 100%!
If it's ready and the issue persists, we suggest the following steps:
While the game is downloading and installing onto your console, please let the process complete before accessing or launching the game as this can cause further issues with your installation.